Pope Benedict XVI remarks – A Lahori Perspective
![]()
Recent comments by Pope Benedict XVI during his speech in a German university have sparked wide spread condemnation and protests worldwide. Like other cities of Pakistan, religious parties have arranged a demonstrations in Lahore too.
I think Pope didn’t get a good advice this time, which is usually the case whenever he is making a speech. It was obvious that his remarks will provoke a controversy. But without going into a debate we should first read the full text of speech he made and then comment. I have read the full text of Pope’s speech available here. The remarks (you can read exact remarks and the background in 2nd and 3rd paragraph of his full speech) which have been taken as most offensive are actually quoted from a book recounting a conversation between 14th-century Byzantine Christian Emperor Manuel Paleologos II and “an educated Persian” on the truths of Christianity and Islam. I think he quoted an excerpt to start a thought provoking debate between great cultures of this world. Specially after reading the last paragraph, I do not think he himself agrees with the views of Emperor Manuel Paleologos II but he was just quoting it to start a debate. I am not sure though that he used enough or right words to convey his intentions clearly and that’s where I personally see the problem.
The last paragraph is worth reading though where he talks about need for a dialogue between different religions and cultures. “A just consideration of the religious dimension is, in fact, an essential premise for fruitful dialogue with the great cultures and religions of the world.” And then he carries on “the world’s profoundly religious cultures see this exclusion of the divine from the universality of reason as an attack on their most profound convictions”
After Pope’s apology today, I hope the controversy should end now and focus should be shifted on contents of his speech. There is definitely a need for positive and healthy dialogue between two great religions of the world. After all it’s one world we all share and it’s extremely important to understand and respect each other’s views and beliefs. There is a lot to be done on our side to show people the real face of Islam which is its message of peace and that can only be done by convincing people with logic and dialogue.



